Rooms are a bit chilly in the winter despite having a portable heater.

Amazing location with lots of animals. Great amenities, good food and friendly staff

Stayed in August 2025

Wonderful hotel in a special location. Facilities and bedrooms are tasteful and comfortable, the grounds are well maintained and everywhere you look there is something to discover. The “ferry” ride to the island was easy to arrange whenever it was needed.

Stayed in July 2025

Everything! Decor, boat ride, scenery, facilities, staff, restaurant were all exceptional.

Stayed in July 2025

Finding some dead flies -or almost dead ones- around, here and there. Though there was a broom at disposal, we just swapped them out. And at least there was no mosquito, thanks to the natural repellent!! There was also no hot water unfortunately, we tried all the sink-opener position, but never had. But it was not a big deal for us, and a good cold shower is good for your health. :) There were not a lot of people around -which is nice- but what I want to say is regarding the curtains in the bathroom. They don't hide anything, they are actually pretty transparent, and we can literally see everything from the outside. I didn't trust my friend at the beginning because it looked like it was fine from the inside, but we do distinguish pretty much everything from the outside. We put the extra towels we had to hide it.

Everything was very good. We had the chance to see the zebras! The staff was very lovely, open and welcoming. Helping us to book some activities they have contacts with. The view of the island is very nice. They have a cat that came to sleep in our accommodation!! -That was one of the best moments hehe. The place was very comfy. The kitchen is dully furnished. There is a little living room area. You can totally go to the grocery store and cook, make tea, coffee, toasts... There is a body blanket to stay around if it's cold, a heater if it's really cold. Extra blankets also. A fridge and everything you need to feel at home to be honest. It was an incredible experience for me. The decorations and colours were natural orientated: white green and brown - it was soft and calming. I loved it all.

Stayed in June 2025

nothing

We loved to stay here! it’s special and we’ll definitely come back in the future :) Big thanks to all the staff members

Stayed in April 2025

A hot tub is advertised but actually it is just a bath not a hot tub spa

Decor is superb. Rooms are beautiful and well equipped.

Stayed in May 2025

Nothing - all good

Stanley island was a unique experience - we totally loved it. Getting picked up by boat and driven to the island, checking into a very nice room, and enjoying the tranquility of the place. But the best part are the zebras strolling around the island. Very special. Good food and friendly staff rounded up our excellent experience. Thank you Stanley Island Team.

Stayed in May 2025

Outstanding staff! Made the stay even more perfect. Thanks Zee!

Stayed in April 2025

It’s so beautiful and staff was very helpful

Stayed in April 2025

Most beautiful location. Beautiful and comfortable room, very good restaurant and super nice views. Every detail is so well-thought out. Would love to come back one day!

Stayed in April 2025

Stanley Island is a true hidden gem! Every moment of our short stay was magical, from the ferry trip, the beautiful, peaceful decor in the rooms to walking under the twinkling lights on the pathways for our delicious dinner at Stowaway restaurant! We will definitely be back! (PS - the photo's cannot capture the beauty of this island, you need to see it for yourself)

Stayed in April 2025

Great service, delish food and an amazing experience seeing the zebra.

Stayed in April 2025

We were in the bottom room so we could here the people above us constantly walking around.

The experience is unique with the location and zebras on the property. The staff and food were both excellent.

Stayed in March 2025

Must visit when in plettenberg bay - beautiful nature and of course the zebras! Very friendly staff Comfortable beds Very clean Self catering wasn’t premium: kitchenette was outdated with loose tap and doors that didn’t close properly, unstable dining table Breakfast portions are too small

Stayed in March 2025

This is a very special place… Staying on the island is so peaceful and with all the animals around The property is super well maintained, the rooms are amazing, clean and all updated! The staff were amazing, super helpful. The restaurant food was also great! Zebras were a 10/10

Stayed in March 2025

Location is perfect to easily visit all the main scenic points on the Garden Route.

Stayed in March 2025

One of the highlights of our trip was staying at Stanley island. From getting on the boat to the island, to checking out, the whole experience was amazing. All the facilities are modern, clean and beautifully appointed. The rooms are well equipped, stylish and comfortable. The food is delicious with outstanding service. Best of all, the Zebras are the stars of the show. The heard of 7 Zebras come to the garden area outside the room every day, such an incredible experience to have your morning coffee while watching these graceful animals.

Stayed in March 2025

It’s a very nice island, we will go back

Stayed in March 2025

We really enjoyed the SUP boards but they were quite expensive.

We liked the small touches like the Nespresso machine and nice glassware and cups. We liked that there was bubble bath and the option to braai on the nice evenings (we also like that you had wood ect on the island). The island is also close to plett if you need to go into town for anything.

Stayed in March 2025

I didn't dislike anything

The zebras and buck roaming freely around. The modern well done room decors and wow beds

Stayed in March 2025

The staff was so sweet. They gave us some champagne and chocolate when we said it was our honeymoon. Also Shaun the cat ❤️

Stayed in March 2025

Unfortunately we did not have hot water for the first day of our stay.

Location is amazing. The staff were very friendly, and walking with the Zebras as an absolute treat.

Stayed in March 2025

This is an exceptional place to stay, a romantic small island, where you are close to nature with zebra’s and a variety of birds outside the window.

Stayed in January 2025

Very calming and beautifully done! My friend go a massage done and claim that it was the best one she every received. Reception and all staff is just lovely and the service does not leave anything to be desired!

Stayed in February 2025