Skip to main content
  1. Hotel reviews homepage
  2. USA hotel reviews
  3. New York State hotel reviews
  4. New York hotel reviews
  5. Reviews of The Whitby Hotel

Reviews of The Whitby Hotel 5 stars

18 West 56th Street, New York, NY 10019, United States

#1 of 429 hotels in New York

Guests' Choice

Review score

Based on 103 hotel reviews

9.5

Score breakdown

  • Cleanliness

    9.8

  • Comfort

    9.9

  • Location

    9.6

  • Facilities

    9.5

  • Staff

    9.5

  • Value for money

    8.3

  • Free WiFi

    9.5

100% verified reviews

Real guests. Real stays. Real opinions.

Read more- opens a dialog box
Write a review

Showing 1 – 25

  • Reviewed: 3 September 2025

    10
    Really enjoyed the stay
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Very little

    Almost everything slightly light on lifts but really well decorated rooms good bathrooms buzzy bar/restaurant area

    Stayed in September 2025

  • Reviewed: 26 June 2025

    9.0
    Will be back
    • Business trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Deluxe Top Floor
    • Stayed 7 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Service at the restaurant was sluggish

    The design, the cleanliness

    Stayed in May 2025

  • Reviewed: 23 June 2025

    10
    Perfect in every way
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Deluxe Top Floor
    • Stayed 1 night

    All was good

    The decor was fabulous throughout the property. Loved the ceiling height and large windows in the room.

    Stayed in June 2025

  • Reviewed: 7 June 2025

    10
    Food, location , staff, housekeeping all a 10
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Junior Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Frederick at concierge was very helpful with shipping my boxes and was eager to please. Entire entry staff was perfect

    Stayed in June 2025

  • Reviewed: 19 May 2025

    10
    best in NYC
    • Business trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Luxury Room
    • Stayed 5 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    everything romm was very comfortable desing is cool excellent location nice stuff amazing food

    Stayed in April 2025

  • Reviewed: 13 May 2025

    10
    Most inspiring hotel ever
    • Business trip
    • People with friends
    • Deluxe Top Floor
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    nothing.

    loved loved loved the interior. Bought two books by the designer which theybsell at the hotel. The rooms are beautiful and very spacious and comfortable. The food in the restaurant was delicious, breakfast, afternoon tea and dinner.

    Stayed in May 2025

  • Reviewed: 12 May 2025

    8.0
    I'd definitly stay there again!
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Luxury Room
    • Stayed 1 night

    Room service-breakfast eggs were cold.

    Beautiful, boutique feel hotel in the heart of mid-town. The bar/restaurant played live jazz on the night it arrived and a trio the following night. My room was a junior suite and it was spacious. Bathroom had. a deep tub with a TV.

    Stayed in May 2025

  • Reviewed: 11 May 2025

    10
    I enjoyed everything. Staff was very helpful and cheerful.
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Deluxe Top Floor
    • Stayed 6 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    I only had room service for breakfast and I enjoyed it

    Stayed in May 2025

  • Reviewed: 10 May 2025

    10
    Amazing, see you again!
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Luxury Room
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Great location, clean, pleasant and courteous staff, awesome food and drinks! Will definitely stay with this family of hotels going forward.

    Stayed in May 2025

  • Reviewed: 31 March 2025

    10
    One of the nicest hotels ever!
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Deluxe Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    Everything - the style, the location, the kindness of the staff…

    Stayed in March 2025

  • Reviewed: 20 March 2025

    10
    Excellent service in a high end area
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Superior Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    Intimate feeland decor

    Stayed in March 2025

  • Reviewed: 5 January 2025

    10
    Would 100% recommend and come back.
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Luxury Room
    • Stayed 4 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    The big rooms, lovely bathroom, comfy bed and the very beautiful bar area.

    The art decor, the location and the friendly staff who was there to help with everything and even very good recommendations.

    Stayed in January 2025

  • Reviewed: 3 January 2025

    10
    magical
    • Couple
    • Superior Room
    • Stayed 5 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    loved everything

    the decor, location and the people

    Stayed in January 2025

  • Reviewed: 31 December 2024

    10
    Memorable, as always…
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Terrace Suite
    • Stayed 3 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Nothing

    Design, the Welcome and location

    Stayed in December 2024

  • Reviewed: 5 November 2024

    10
    Perfect for a Marathon weekend.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Top Floor
    • Stayed 4 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Nothing not to like

    Everything

    Stayed in November 2024

  • Reviewed: 2 November 2024

    9.0
    Superb
    • Leisure trip
    • Group
    • Luxury Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Great location, friendly staff

    Stayed in November 2024

  • Reviewed: 4 October 2024

    10
    Keep it up ❤️
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Junior Suite
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    Nothing

    Everything Room Restaurant Staff are very friendly

    Stayed in October 2024

  • Reviewed: 26 August 2024

    10
    What a classy hotel!
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Luxury Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    Location was fabulous. Easy to get everywhere.

    Stayed in August 2024

  • Reviewed: 17 August 2024

    10
    Great short vacation was had by all.
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Deluxe Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    The staff at the front; reception, concierge, parking and valet were fabulous. They couldn’t have been and kinder. We would come back for sure.

    Stayed in August 2024

  • Reviewed: 23 July 2024

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Family with young children
    • Junior Terrace Suite
    • Stayed 4 nights

    it was sometimes challenging to get someone on the phone (room service) at busy hours. but whenever i went to the reception, people were more than helpful - outstanding helpful.

    We loved the friendly and happy design of the hotel and rooms; it was extravagant and gave a good feeling. Employees especially concierge have been very helpful and friendly. we loved the walking distance to central park in the morning and the live jazz evening in the hotel bar for evening. i was surprised about the silence in the rooms, especially since we have been so centrally located. We loved our terrace to sit in the mornings or evenings. we will be back again!

    Stayed in July 2024

  • Reviewed: 22 June 2024

    9.0
    Definitely, Firmdale Group
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Superior Room
    • Stayed 3 nights

    The heating mechanism of the towel rack (towel rail) was stopped, although this may be unavoidable since it was summer. It was a bit disappointing, as a warm towel rack is a pleasant thing. Also, there was no tea or coffee in the room, so I asked for a tea set (tea tray). It was nice that they brought it to me right away, but I was disappointed that it did not come with a milk pot or that the set was not updated daily. I am sure they would have done it if we had told them, but since our stay was short this time, we did not dare to request it either. In addition, we had mistakenly thought that all rooms in the Firmdale Hotel Group were equipped with a bathtub, so we were a little disappointed that there was no bathtub in this room, even though it was our own mistake.

    It is a member of the Firmdale Hotels group, and its atmosphere, facilities, and services are almost the same as those of the Haymarket Hotel, which is also a member of the Firmdale Hotels group. The staff is friendly and helpful, and when I asked for something, they were quick to respond. I had to leave my key with them every time I went out, but I guess many people remember the room numbers of guests and their room numbers, so when I came back from outing and went to the reception, I found my key right away.

    Stayed in June 2024

  • Reviewed: 21 June 2024

    9.0
    innovative, artistic, different. An experience just being there. would love to do it again one day.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Junior Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights

    quite expensive, but outstanding. attention to detail was incredible.

    staff were first class. Friendly, competent, next level.

    Stayed in June 2024

  • Reviewed: 20 June 2024

    8.0
    It’s a great hotel. Super location. Smaller size room but with everything needing. Nice and thoughtful gifts in room whi
    • Business trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Deluxe Top Floor
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    The doorman is not every one friendly. I have encountered one in bad mood when I arrived the hotel

    Lovely hotel, lovely people

    Stayed in April 2024

  • Reviewed: 23 May 2024

    10
    Beautiful hotel, attentive staff, great location
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe Room
    • Stayed 4 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    The staff, location and decor

    Stayed in May 2024

Showing 1 – 25

We Price Match
We Price Match
Low rates • No booking fees • Find cheaper? We'll refund the difference!