All the shared spaces are now part of the private club and no longer part of the Jane Hotel. Disappointed not to have anywhere to sit and do a bit of work, and that these spaces are still advertised on Booking.com as part of the hotel. No hot water for any of the times two of us tried to shower (early morning, morning, midday, evening, late evening).

The room we stayed in was a bunk room and really did have the feel of early 20th century sailors quarters. There is still a sense of authenticity for the (incredibly small, but utilitarian) rooms. The shared bathrooms were really clean.

Stayed in June 2025

There was construction going on throughout the building with no access to any sort of common lounge area or cafe, and you had to use a freight elevator - I think I should have been given a discount for that. Also the shared bathrooms were cramped, awkward trying to brush your teeth next to a dude shaving lol.

It was fun to stay in the little cabin room for a night, and I enjoyed the decor, nice choice of fabrics, wall coverings, the beautiful wood paneling, etc. and it's in a great part of town.

Stayed in November 2024

The room is quite small.

Location is perfect

Stayed in December 2024

Absolutely zero options for work (and unfriendly staff) - no kettle even downstairs to boil water. No place to work. Rooms were teeny tiny. Showers were under repair so I never got a hot shower

Tiny Room was clean, nice panelling and appointments, temp fine. Bathrooms were clean. There was electricity in the room to charge.

Stayed in October 2024

Shared bathrooms were unisex, didn’t feel very private. My room was sweltering, heating on full blast and unable to turn it down. I was advised to use the AC which only helped somewhat.

Good location and friendly staff

Stayed in December 2024

-Smell is bad -Rooms are for the dwarfs - they didn’t mentioned first floor renovation

Location and authenticity Surprisingly clean, conditioner worked

Stayed in December 2024

We understood that work was being done but it meant that the feeling in the hotel was quite strange. The shared bathrooms were fine except that some of the people using them seemed to be living at the hotel. This meant that they often used the bathrooms to clean out old tubs of food or other utensils which it seemed they’d been using to cook in their rooms. My friend had a scary incident with one such person who made an inappropriate comment and after that we only ever went to the shared bathrooms together. There were no locks on the door and nothing to prevent anyone on the street from walking in, and at night it was rare that someone was working the desk.

The location is fantastic and the area feels safe.

Stayed in October 2024

Only thing is that the room gets extremely hot as it’s very small and you can’t turn off the heater. I had to open my window which had no fly netting to be able to sleep reasonably comfortably and not sweat.

The location is so great! The staff are friendly enough. Clean place. it’s good value for being right in New York. I do recommend staying here if you’re a tourist like we were because of the location and value for money.

Stayed in December 2024

I wasn't aware that The Jane's lobby/restaurant/bar had been lost to another development and that it is under significant renovation. This should be disclosed more clearly on the website because it affects the quality of guests' stay.

The Jane is an old favorite that I've stayed at several times before. It's affordable, with a good location.

Stayed in December 2024

Cost

Quiet

Stayed in November 2024

I expected to share a bathroom but with more personal space. This was like a coed dorm and not all guests respond appropriately. For instance a guest on our floor was washing up at the main sink instead of the shower stall. We had to walk past him to get to a toilet stall.

Stayed in November 2024

A private club is under construction in the building so the hotel no longer has its elegant lobby, nor will it ever have the lobby again. The rooftop and the restaurant were also closed when I was there.

These little pod rooms seem to have been built 100 years ago to resemble sleeper cars on a train. Everything is in arms reach!

Stayed in November 2024

Musty smell

Location, low cost

Stayed in October 2024

Construction zone. Plastic on hallway. Work started before 9am and construction people walking around shared bathroom.

Nice people and great location

Stayed in October 2024

Location was great and staff was very nice.

Stayed in October 2024

The building disruption.

The cabin concept.

Stayed in September 2024

It has been under reconstruction for several years now. All these fancy lobby and bars are closed. Only tiny rooms and bathroom on the floor. Rooms are OK. However, my experience was ruined because it doesn’t said anywhere that they closed every facility there due to renovation.

Nothing.

Stayed in September 2024

No tea or coffee making facilities. Tiny rooms . I think that this hotel, although charming in its way, is vastly over-priced, even for New York. My daughter lives in upState NY and so we just had one night in the city, but needing 2 rooms, it was a very expensive night.

Location was good.

Stayed in August 2024

The Hotel has permanently eliminated its restaurant and rooftop bar. The cabin-sized rooms are really too small.

The location in the West Village was good.

Stayed in September 2024

Normal place

Ok

Stayed in May 2024

The hotel is under construction - not just restaurants - and they start very early. The only part of the original hotel that was visible was my room. Room was very tiny but cozy.

My room was as stated - charming and tiny but in need of some repairs Shared baths were clean and always available. Staff went above and beyond to make my stay comfortable. Excellent area!

Stayed in July 2024

I had breakfast at dinner time

Stayed in June 2024

They're doing a multi million dollar renovation so during the weekdays it's filled with construction workers. Attempting to use the shower or lavatory was interesting as it was generally full. It's also coed so that may make some people feel uncomfortable. The rooms require a brass rod to complete the circuit to work the electric. Hopefully they will modernize the electric with the rest of the facilities.

It was comfortable. I found it to be unique and historical. The employees were very nice.

Stayed in June 2024

I have stayed there before and the lobby and hotel was so charming. But with the construction going on it was so dusty and even with the warning they provided I wasn’t ready for the construction site atmosphere.

Location

Stayed in May 2024