The shower in our room wasn’t very good

Beautiful little hotel in Restaurant Row about a three min walk from Times Square

Stayed in September 2025

Although breakfast was included, I anticipated a few more things would be available; however, with so many choices around the hotel it wasn’t a huge issue or deterrent.

Great location and the suit was a solid size.

Stayed in September 2025

Location

Stayed in August 2025

We had a room facing the front - the Main Street, and it was very noisy at night - we would not stay in a room facing the front of the building again.

The location was super central and it was easy to get anywhere and everywhere. The complimentary breakfast was tasty, provided more than the usual options and the staff were very helpful and continuously cleaned and refreshed and refilled the various food options. All very aesthetically presented.

Stayed in September 2025

Washroom was a bit old fashioned with very small wash basin but definitely very clean and functional.

Very good breakfast particularly the breakfast venue. It was relatively spacious compared to total guests accommodation at the property. Further, very friendly and respectful staff managing the breakfast. Property location also very good. Overall we enjoyed our stay at the property.

Stayed in August 2025

The location was convenient to everything! The staff was kind and helpful.

Stayed in August 2025

Room is very small and had a strong cleaning odor

This hotel is located 2 blocks from Times Square and the Theater area. It is a small cute bouquet type hotel

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

Great location. A large, comfortable, room with excellent facilities. Helpful and friendly staff… they even left a bottle of fizz in our room as they noticed it was my birthday! The breakfast (though not particularly varied) was pretty good too.

Stayed in August 2025

The breakfast is not very big and they didn’t have any glutenfree options (I asked in advance), but I took my own bread, that was no problem.

Awesome rooftop, the room was small but very cosy and the bed was comfortable!

Stayed in August 2025

Room 501 has beautiful balcony and view! Was clean and fresh. Nice touch with classical music playing. Perfect set up for 5 people!

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

Location, room size, cleanliness.

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

Our room was clean,comfortable and quiet. Updated Bathroom /walk in shower. Two chairs, desk, wardrobe, fridge, small sink and Keurig coffee maker. Compact small check-in area but attended 24 hours. Luggage can be stored . Breakfast was fresh pastries, fruit , yogurt ..and well serviced . Small safe.

Stayed in August 2025

Separate building to roof top seating & breakfast. Steep stairs, no lift access to our room.

Room layout & cleanliness

Stayed in August 2025

None

Perfect, location, staff, facilities, food…. Everything….

Stayed in August 2025

There is no elevator in the townhouse side where we stayed which could be an issue for some. The staff handled our luggage so this was not a problem for us.

Our room was spacious, clean and stylish and the bed was very comfortable. Staff were friendly and welcoming. You can’t beat the location if you’re seeing a broadway show, as theaters and dozens of restaurants are within close proximity.

Stayed in August 2025

Fabulous location and very helpful staff.

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing…

Superb location close to Times Square, theatres and restaurants. We had the 2 bedroom suite with the terrace which was outstanding. Enjoying a glass of wine looking out at the city lights was breathtaking and really made the experience very special. The Hotel Scherman team was awesome and really looked after all our needs. For us, this is the go to hotel when staying in Manhattan and highly recommend. Thanks to all the team for a wonderful experience.

Stayed in August 2025

The location was incredible, it was super comfortable, clean, impeccable, the terrace was a plus We got a personal welcoming letter in the room they made us feel special The staff was super welcoming and we even had an upgrade to the penthouse Worth staying Breakfast was really good and there were many options for a continental breakfast! What an amazing gem the Scherman Hotel

Stayed in August 2025

I loved my corner room with the huge windows. Common rooms were stylish and "happening." Staff was friendly and helpful.

Stayed in June 2025

Nothing

Perfect location with extremely comfortable penthouse suite

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

Everything

Stayed in August 2025

Getting into you bags prior to check-in (since they were not right at the check-in desk as in many hotels but instead stored on another floor) was a bit unwieldy...but the staff were great about bringing bags down we needed!

Overall...the best hotel I have ever stayed in in NYC! Keep up the good work!

Stayed in July 2025

Not much

Great location, big room (for NYC) with queen beds, nice bathroom, good breakfast, nice roof deck

Stayed in August 2025

Need egg cups with boiled eggs at breakfast — which is otherwise well-stocked in an airy, light-filled space.

A truly nice boutique hotel nestled next to New York City’s theatre district, in the midst of dozens of great restaurants. There are great places for take-out nearby if you like, and a wonderful wine store just steps away on Ninth Avenue — and a very comfortable furnished rooftop to enjoy your picnic looking out across Midtown West.

Stayed in August 2025