Gorgeous property! Beautiful rooms and delicious dinner.

Stayed in June 2025

Expensive

Staff was exceptionally helpful

Stayed in July 2025

Very clean and nice. staff very friendly

Stayed in June 2025

Gorgeous in and out. Thoughtful details. Fantastic tavern on site.

Stayed in July 2025

There was someone else’s hair throughout the bathroom, probably from whoever cleaned the room but didn’t get all the hair removed. Some in the corners where a mop would go, some in the sink, some in the bathtub. No trash can in the room, which I’m accustomed to anywhere else- only in the bathroom which meant all trash had to go there. Breakfast was delicious and filling, but simple- scrambled eggs, bacon, muffins, etc. I anticipated a more unique breakfast spread based on experience at other b&bs.

Beautiful historic b&b. All of the staff were extremely kind especially the innkeeper. Margo room is very nice, comfortable, and beautiful view with a connected balcony.

Stayed in May 2025

I wasn’t a fan of the pillows.

Tasteful, clean, charming, welcoming. The room and bed were exquisite, great bathroom and shower too. Delicious hot breakfast. The staff, especially Beverly.

Stayed in February 2025

Fire place flame was tiny not effective at all.

Stayed in February 2025

Very helpful staff.

Stayed in October 2024

We would have liked a cereal choice and the ability to make toast to have with butter and preserves

The breakfast was good.

Stayed in August 2024

Entire experience was more than I expected. Excellent

Stayed in August 2024

😃

😀

Stayed in July 2024

Nothing

This property is beautifully maintained with enormous old charm.

Stayed in July 2024

nothing

Everything I absolutely loved the warm and welcoming atmosphere of the inn. The homey decor and cozy environment made it feel like a true retreat. The cleanliness was impeccable, with fresh linens that had a delightful, clean scent. The staff stood out the most – they were incredibly helpful, polite, and genuinely friendly, always going above and beyond to make my stay comfortable. The overall ambiance was serene and inviting, providing a perfect blend of comfort and excellent service. It was an exceptional experience that exceeded all my expectations.

Stayed in July 2024

Wish I had found it sooner!!

Unique, beautiful, was very well appointed with wonderful food and a truly comfortable bed

Stayed in June 2024

It was a minor inconvenience, but the wifi kept disconnecting.

Everything! The breakfast was fantastic. The room was clean and comfortable. We had dinner downstairs too and the food was absolutely amazing. This was our second stay at the Stagecoach and we’ll definitely be back.

Stayed in February 2024

Absolutely nothing. It is perfection!

The Stagecoach Inn is lovely. It boasts beautiful grounds and a magnificent lodging and dining experience with exceptional staff.

Stayed in January 2024

One problem, fireplace did not work, they try to fixed it, but it didn't work, was disappointed about that.

Breakfast was excellent. Dinner was very good, and the service for both dinner and breakfast was excellent Accommodations were very good

Stayed in November 2023

At dinner it felt they were understaffed. But all food was wonderful.

Everything

Stayed in September 2023

Genuinely friendly staff provided many personal touches that made us feel welcome. The rooms were tastefully decorated and well maintained. After a long car ride, it was great to have a bar and food on site. Lovely grounds.

Stayed in September 2023

5 rooms total in this large beautiful inn so you’ll feel like you have the whole place to yourself. Absolutely gorgeous and thoughtful down to very last detail. Most comfortable bed I’ve ever slept in. They make you feel so welcomed, like family. I can’t wait to visit again. A++

Stayed in September 2023

Exceptional service, great atmosphere.

Stayed in September 2023

Nothing

Most comfortable bed I have ever slept in. The staff made us feel like family. Breakfast was phenomenal. I always find something wrong but just can't this time. I would recommend this 100 times over. I can't wait to return. This will be a regular stop for us!

Stayed in July 2023

The property was so cute, loved the way it was decorated. It felt like you were at home but with the luxuries of being at an inn.

Stayed in July 2023

The breakfast was a disappointment. Admittedly, the first day we were late coming down so didn't expect much, but the only option was scrambled eggs and bacon, with the addition of banana bread and bananas & oranges on day 2. Not what we were expecting from a "continental breakfast". I had to attend a virtual meeting and the internet was a bit too weak to cope with that, but this isn't the type of place you come to to work, so enjoy & switch off!

What a stunning inn! My sister and I had a lovely two nights here. The staff were friendly and attentive and our room was very comfortable and quiet. There's a lovely garden and living room space that guests can use too: all very peaceful and relaxing. We were lucky to be there on the day that there was the food market in Goshen and enjoyed that. From a location perspective, it's conveniently located off the main road in Goshen, with easy access by car to hiking trails.

Stayed in July 2023