Very dark in the Back parking lot.

Love the doors that go out to the pool . Clean rooms . Love that there's a sink outside & inside the bathroom . Love the back porch I love to sit and have coffee over looking the marine . Town is very close to hotel . Nice front desk staff .

Stayed in August 2025

Beautiful surroundings

Impeccable clean

Stayed in July 2025

would prefer a larger TV screen so we can see titles from the bed or the sofa in our room along with seeing the channel guide from a greater distance.

Lovely inn in a fabulous location. Attentive staff and maintained quite well. Rooms are cleaned daily and maidstaff is very good. We celebrated a special anniversary while there and the front desk sent us a wonderful bottle of wine of our choice with 2 flutes in a chilled ice bucket, what a lovely and caring touch! Limited Beach passes are available daily for the local bay and ocean beaches which is wonderful amenity. Nice pool with lounge chairs and tables, chairs and umbrellas set up so you can just relax pn the premisis. Free Continental breakfast available daily!

Stayed in July 2025

Please replace the mini size soaps with soap and shampoo dispensers in the bathrooms.

Great stay! Very nice location. The staff are so friendly and very helpful. Staff are excellent. Value was not there as it is all overpriced at this time. What can you do!? I would go back.

Stayed in June 2025

Spacious and clean rooms, great quiet location, the pool looked super nice, too. Very comfortable beds and lovely views onto the harbour. Special thanks to John and Ean for making sure we had a great stay!

Stayed in July 2025

Venue well located, comfy bed and complimentary breakfast

Stayed in July 2025

Stay was amazing, we loved it and will be back. Room is very spacious, cozy and clean.

Stayed in June 2025

I understand that it’s the height of the summer season but $600 for Saturday night is way too expensive for that hotel. If we didn’t have to go down there for christening and we would’ve never booked there at that price. But it also supply demand right.

The property was located, centrally in town, walkable to all the shops and restaurants.

Stayed in June 2025

Could have had better linens

Location, cleanliness, and price

Stayed in May 2025

Our stay at the Sag Harbor Inn was absolutely delightful. The room was beautifully decorated, the staff warm and welcoming, and the bed incredibly comfortable. We especially appreciated the high-quality bath toiletries and the fantastic harbor view—such a perfect location. We can’t wait to return this fall!

Stayed in May 2025

The large comfortable rooms with nice toiletries. Short walk to centre of town. Nicely heated in cold weather.

Beautiful and quaint B and B located a short walk to the town centre. Really enjoyed our stay here and would stay again

Stayed in May 2025

we were out of season - shame that the pool was not in use

Beautiful setting, we think one of best in island Kind and friendly staff love the balcony

Stayed in May 2025

The cost of the room is pricey for that time of the year. This was our second year going for a mini vacation and it was very costly for a 2 day stay

I enjoy the breakfast , you don’t have to leave the Inn so you get coffee and something to eat and go back to the room to relax

Stayed in December 2024

Cozy room.

Stayed in November 2024

That we didnt stay longer! Also loved the harbor view only a pity the weather didnt permit us to sit out on the terrace!

Loved the warm feeling as soon as you walk through the door in a cold and rainy afternoon. John on reception went oit of his way to make us feel at home. Thanks for the delicious local wine!

Stayed in November 2024

The continental breakfast was very limited.

Everything was very clean. I like that the property is kind of tucked away, but close enough to good restaurants and shops.

Stayed in November 2024

Some of the bathroom amenities are too outdated…and handicap accessible room is not updated to best standard.

The location and Staff are excellent ! Rooms are comfortable but a bit tight in space .

Stayed in November 2024

Wall mounted TV was too small and not "Smart". The electrical outlet next to the bathroom sink was a non-GFCI receptacle - dangerous and non-code.

Stayed in November 2024

Breakfast needs to be way better quality given the cost of the room! In comparison, Hampton Inns offer much cheaper accomodation but their continental breakfasts are excellent.

Location excellent; breakfast less than average; front desk people--Kathy, Ean fantasic...the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Stayed in October 2024

The continental breakfast was ok, but would have preferred a full hot breakfast.

Stayed in October 2024

Breakfast was nice and I appreciated having coffee available all day.

Stayed in October 2024

A very comfortable hotel within an easy walk to shops and restaurants

Stayed in September 2024

Choice of bakery items at breakfast premade ones were poor in taste

Typical

Stayed in September 2024

Would have preferred water in room upon arrival

Location is great / everyone is kind and helpful - 2nd time staying there and plan to come again - love the dock view from my room -, enjoyed the quiet outdoor patio enabling me to get work done in a lovely setting and scenic view.

Stayed in September 2024