Staff was expectionally nice and accommodating.

Stayed in August 2025

Very little to dislike. If I was being picky the room was a bit small but this is to be expected in a guest house.

This Inn is the quintessential Hamptons stay. We absolutely loved it and we were disappointed we didn’t stay here longer. The building is beautiful and styled in the typical Hamptons style architecture. The big porch was lovely to have breakfast on or to relax on with a drink after a day out. The location is magnificent with East Hampton village centre just a 2 minute walk away. It is a perfect base to explore the Hamptons from. Another big bonus of staying here is that they provide the beach parking permits. The staff were excellent, so friendly and went above and beyond to make our stay extra special. They were very informative about the local area and gave us some great tips for restaurants and things to do. We would consider Mill House Inn our first choice for when we ever return to the Hamptons and could not recommend it more.

Stayed in June 2025

The quietness and friendly staff were attentive and very nice!

Stayed in February 2025

Nothing not to like.

The property is very quiet and the staff are friendly making you feel at home. We had suite 19 and was lovely, a real treat and very spacious. The staff can’t do enough for you.

Stayed in September 2024

The room was a little on the small side with limited plug sockets and the only mirror was in the bathroom.

The location was excellent and the room very comfortable. The staff were friendly and happy to help. A snack bar offering a huge range of sweets, nuts and freshly baked cookies was a lovely touch and very much appreciated.

Stayed in September 2024

You have to preorder breakfast the evening beforehand which means that you have to be organised!

Excellent location and only a 5 mins walk to the shops and restaurants. The accommodation was first class and our suite was very spacious and incredibly comfortable.

Stayed in September 2024

Carpets were old and a but grubby. Noise from the highway. The Inn could really use an update

The staff were amazing and quaintness and history of the Inn. Breakfasts were great.

Stayed in June 2024

Nada

Polite Staff. Quality food. Location.

Stayed in March 2024

We arrived to a lovely welcome from Dawn. After a bad experience the night before at another location Dawn and Kenny upgraded us to the next level suite. The room was lovely and the bed was so comfy .The location of the INN was perfect and overlooked a nice green and was in a very quiet area. Breakfast was great and Kenny showed us around the other rooms including the master suites which were stunning . A lovely stay and we will definitely stay again if we are in the area again.

Stayed in December 2023

Breakfast was just okay.

It was a wonderful place and the staff was really wonderful.

Stayed in February 2023

Everything

You need to tell your guests that they can’t get breakfast until 8/30 which for $1250 a night is totally unacceptable No staff

Stayed in July 2025

Nothing. Everything was great.

Absolutely loved breakfast, the stay and the accommodations. A big thank you to Dawn and the owner who upgraded my wife and I to a beautiful room for our 10th anniversary. Thank you.

Stayed in May 2025

Dawn greeted us after a long travel day in the rain and could not have been more welcoming. We truly appreciated the care in which she checked us in and made sure we were comfortable.

Stayed in December 2024

Dated interior including old, saggy uncomfortable mattress, no pool despite picture and description, breakfast in 15min slots, no room service, damp smell of mold

Location in East Hampton

Stayed in July 2024

This is NOT a luxury hotel at all. It is egregious that they are charging $1600/night for a motel with very dated rooms and frustrating customer service. Having traveled extensively globally, I'm shocked by the rave reviews for this motel. The place was neither charming nor welcoming. From the unnecessarily complicated process for booking breakfast to never cleaning our musty guest room to locking the water refrigerator at night to stale snacks and tepid water for tea, I do not recommend this place at all. The process to book breakfast is unnecessarily complicated and laughable. You must book the night before with breakfast starting late at 8am and only offered in 15 min increments. God forbid you come downstairs without booking to an empty dining room and get lectured for not following the process when you only want yogurt and toast. It felt like we were on candid camera every morning. The chef was the only bright light in our always frustrating morning interactions. We bonded with the other hotel guests who just rolled their eyes and shared their stories of their frustrating poor experience. I'm infuriated that I shelled out $1600/night for this run down motel. Highway robbery. Do not stay here.

Location - I could escape to other places and not spend a minute here beyond sleeping

Stayed in July 2024

Breakfast was quite tasty, and I appreciated the fact that they attempted to accommodate me or feed me, even on the first morning when I arrived late, and had not made my breakfast reservation

Stayed in May 2024

Nothing! Everything was perfect. Our train was delayed and they allowed us to have a late checkout so we wouldn't be stranded. It felt like we were staying with friends.

The service was impeccable! Not only was the space beautiful and clean, the staff went the extra mile to make us feel special. We were visiting East Hampton for Mother's Day Weekend and we couldn't have asked for anything more.

Stayed in May 2024

The staff were incredibly helpful and kind. The breakfast was excellent! Very relaxing stay in a super convenient location. Will definitely be staying again for work. 10/10 recommend.

Stayed in March 2024

Can’t say enough about beautiful property and the gracious staff. Attention to detail and an exemplary level of hospitality.

Stayed in March 2024

Nothing to complain about! All good!

Ken and Dawn were exceptionally friendly hosts. Very helpful with local attractions and options for our stay in the area. The Mill House Inn is walking distance to a charming downtown and a short drive to Sag Harbor and the Eastern End of LI. Chef Taylor provided a delightful breakfast, made to order with a fine selection that would exceed anyone's expectations for the morning repast. Fresh brewed coffee, omelettes, fruit+yogurt, oatmeal...anything that you can delight with.

Stayed in March 2024

The staff were sweet but the manager traps you talking endlessly and made us feel always. The blinds in the room were torn and it was all just poorly run.

It is run down and over it cad.

Stayed in January 2024

The breakfast was huge and delicious. I had the breakfast sandwich and my husband had the pancakes. Both were amazing and the coffee was out of this world! The snack bar was also perfect to tide us over until dinner.

Stayed in December 2023

The warm welcome, the friendly and helpful personnel (thank you, Dawn, for your help with restaurant reservations and recommendations), the cosy location and the breakfast made our vacation so much better. If we go back to the Hamptons, we’re coming back to the Mill House Inn.

Stayed in November 2023

I would like to have a bigger closet to store the cloths, but thats not a big issue.

First of all we liked the set-up of the Inn, in a nice garden. The house has an ancient vibe and breaths a warmhearted spirit. The staff are very friendly. The breakfast in very yummy and has just something different than the usual. All day availability of cold and warm drinks and snacks, including the famous cookies. The bedroom is small but extremely cosy, with the surplus of an "open" fire place.

Stayed in November 2023