Skip to main content
  1. Hotel reviews homepage
  2. USA hotel reviews
  3. New York State hotel reviews
  4. Shelter Island Heights hotel reviews
  5. Reviews of West Neck Guesthouse

Reviews of West Neck Guesthouse 2 stars

31 West Neck Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, United States

#2 of 2 hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Guests' Choice

Review score

Based on 21 hotel reviews

7.9

Score breakdown

  • Cleanliness

    8.4

  • Comfort

    8.9

  • Location

    9.1

  • Facilities

    8.0

  • Staff

    7.9

  • Value for money

    7.9

100% verified reviews

Real guests. Real stays. Real opinions.

Read more- opens a dialog box
Write a review

Showing 1 – 21

  • Reviewed: 20 July 2025

    7.0
    Good
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    Pillows and comforter were really uncomfortable Soft feather pillows and a down comforter would make this spot a 10!!

    Location charming house Easy check in

    Stayed in July 2025

  • Reviewed: 2 June 2025

    9.0
    Tranquil and relaxing stay
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights

    Nothing

    They offer coffee and tea in the morning.

    Stayed in May 2025

  • Reviewed: 15 July 2024

    7.0
    Good
    • Leisure trip
    • Solo traveller
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    No blinds on skylights.

    The guest house is lively but lacking amenities including blinds for skylights, hangers in the closet, water glasses, and a hair dryer. For this price these basic things should be provided.

    Stayed in July 2024

  • Reviewed: 13 June 2024

    8.0
    Great place to stay for short term.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights

    N/A

    Location and convience

    Stayed in June 2024

  • Reviewed: 13 September 2023

    8.0
    Overall average.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights

    Rude, noisy neighbors. Saturday was agony, it felt like they were in the room with us. The walls are paper thin. Loud laughing, loud music, absolutely no consideration. But, then suddenly at 1:15am it all stopped. It was almost like something bad happened to them.

    Room was fine

    Stayed in September 2023

  • Reviewed: 15 July 2025

    4.0
    Disappointing
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Bathroom door not closing, cheap synthetic bed sheets, super thin walls

    Location

    Stayed in June 2025

  • Reviewed: 8 October 2024

    6.0
    Clean and relaxing but property could have been much better if kept up to date and things worked.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Run down. Something’s did not work

    Clean room nice bed.

    Stayed in October 2024

  • Reviewed: 23 July 2024

    10
    Would go back next year!
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    We enjoyed and loved everything.

    Close to everything, centrally located. So clean and cozy and roomy for small rental. Even had a patio with seats and a small table. Someone came and cleaned each day. Was amazing experience.

    Stayed in July 2024

  • Reviewed: 24 June 2024

    10
    So wonderful
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Liked everything

    Very good

    Stayed in June 2024

  • Reviewed: 12 June 2024

    10
    Fabulous, fabulous, fabulous, in one sentence.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights

    When a property experience is fabulous, there is little more than that one word to properly convey it. This stay will be my go to from here on.

    Stayed in June 2024

  • Reviewed: 21 October 2023

    10
    We had a great time and would highly recommend.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    A things to do or listing of local restaurants would have been helpful.

    There was no breakfast

    Stayed in September 2023

  • Reviewed: 4 October 2023

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    Very easy contactless check in, Suzanne was great with communication and accommodating requests and making sure we had a great short trip!

    Stayed in October 2023

  • Reviewed: 21 September 2023

    10
    Nice location with plenty of privacy.
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    Very professionally run, grounds were beautifully landscaped, touches such as a note with your name on it, providing check in info. was very thoughtful.

    Stayed in September 2023

  • Reviewed: 27 August 2025

    8.0
    Very good
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in August 2025

  • Reviewed: 16 June 2025

    8.0
    Very good
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in June 2025

  • Reviewed: 17 June 2024

    9.0
    Superb
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in June 2024

  • Reviewed: 29 August 2023

    8.0
    Very good
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in August 2023

  • Reviewed: 31 July 2023

    9.0
    Superb
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • King Suite
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in July 2023

  • Reviewed: 10 July 2023

    8.0
    Very good
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 2 nights
    • Submitted via mobile

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in July 2023

  • Reviewed: 19 September 2024

    10
    Exceptional
    • Leisure trip
    • Couple
    • Deluxe King Room
    • Stayed 1 night
    • Submitted via mobile

    There are no comments available for this review

    Stayed in August 2024

Showing 1 – 21

We Price Match
We Price Match
Low rates • No booking fees • Find cheaper? We'll refund the difference!