Reviews of The Coonamessett 4 stars

I really liked and appreciated the breakfast options. They were healthy and not over complicated. And the space for breakfast was very peaceful and relaxing. Location was excellent- a lot of activity options, even in a walkable distance. My room was spacious and comfortable. Everything I needed. Plus care about the guests was exceptional.

Location. Continental breakfast. Staff

The humidity stuffiness in room

My room looks like a doctors office,all white , if you have a problem walking there is to many steps depending which room they put you in,,, the living room tv is too small for the room

Grounds well kept

Should have a pool

Clean and breakfast lay out beautiful

Thermostat didn’t work

It was beautiful and the staff could not have been more accommodating and friendly.

Nothing

It was very clean and the room we had was very spacious. It was a really pretty room.

Our room was facing a parking lot and had no place to sit outside and have a coffee or read a book. However there was a sitting area by the main office entrance. Would have been nice to have more seating areas on the green grass area.

The staff was very friendly

Much older than pictures represented. Room was not very clean and mattress was very old and uncomfortable. We booked 3 nights but left after 2.

The way it was laid out. The rooms were very spacious. Bed was very comfortable.

I wish they had a pool.

Beautiful facilities in a great location

There was a problem with the AC but staff quickly addressed it, and a window AC unit was a good replacemen

On the positive side, the hotel is situated in a lovely part of Falmouth, which is a charming and picturesque town. The building itself is beautiful, full of old character, and we did appreciate that aspect. We also found the bed to be very comfortable.

However, the negatives far outweighed the positives. The most disruptive issue was the incredibly thin walls. We were kept awake during our first night by persistent noise from the room next door. Even after we raised the issue with staff, nothing was done, and the disturbance continued. On our second night, the power in our room went out entirely, and we had to go and get it fixed ourselves. The room itself was extremely basic. There was no bottled water, no coffee or tea-making facilities, and although there was a fridge, it was completely empty. It all felt quite unthoughtful, especially for the price. Breakfast was another disappointment - the selection was minimal to the point of being almost pointless, and it felt very stingy. Overall, we found the value for money to be very poor. For what the hotel charges per night, the experience felt cheap, inattentive, and ultimately not worth it. We left feeling ripped off and would not choose to stay here again.

Good location. A quick drive to the ferry to take to Martha’s Vineyard and a quick drive or walk to town. Good spread for breakfast and good food at the tavern. Loved the patio for dining outside as well.

No coffee in the room and uncomfortable worn out chairs. Also had two tears in the throw rug where I almost tripped.

To be avoided. It's just a motel with very old furniture. Frayed carpet — perfect for a fall! The bikes were unusable despite the approval of the person at the front desk. Extremely overpriced — we paid the rate of a real five-star hotel. Definitely to be avoided.

All

Pleasant, good parking

Dont like the bar/breakfast area, too dark and not inviting. The deck is nice, but hot

King Deluxe room was very nicely decorated. Staff were friendly and professional. The manager was very professional and took care of an issue we had with the smoke alarm. The grounds by the pond were really pretty and nicely kept. The main lobby of the inn was pretty. The continental breakfast was a plus. We appreciated the hand soap in the bathroom, much better than bar soap. Having two closets was a plus. If you want a nicer view, choose the King Deluxe or the suites. There were a fair amount of rooms/buildings that were just in the middle of the parking lot.

The bathroom had an unpleasant odor, similar to wed wood or perhaps wet wicker since there was a wicker basket under the sink. Having two closets was a plus, but there was no light in one of them and only 5 hangers were provided in total between the two closets. The light switch on the floor was broken for the lamp, we had to keep unplugging it and plugging it back in. They did not have some of the amenities of a regular motel/hotel which would have been nice (e.g. Kurig in room with coffee/tea, ice machine and vending machine on site). Bring your own hair dryer. My handle was sticky and when I requested a new one, both of the other two they brought were sticky and one even had "crud" on it. I ended up just buying my own at CVS. For safety, there should really be a deadbolt on the room doors, especially since there was no lock on the outside door. The 1970's sliding latch is not strong enough and did not make me feel safe.