My stay at “Come As You Are In” was exactly what I needed: comfortable and relaxing. The room was pleasant, and the bed was very comfy, ensuring I slept well. However, what truly made the stay special was **the host**. They were incredibly welcoming from the moment I arrived, genuinely pleasant to talk to, and went out of their way to make sure I had everything I needed. Their hospitality was outstanding and truly the most important part of the experience. Highly recommend for a warm and comfortable getaway.

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

The hosts were very friendly and fun

Stayed in July 2025

We stayed two nights at the house; very clean and well maintained. The breakfast prepared by the host was excellent and also a great opportunity to chat with other guests. We chose Sayville because we were spending the weekend at Fire Island. The host kindly offered to drive us to the ferry station, so we didn’t have to park our car and pay for parking. They have a stunning backyard with a beautiful pool and jacuzzi, though we didn’t get a chance to use it, since our main focus was Fire Island. Overall, a very good experience.

Stayed in July 2025

Access to a beautiful backyard with pool and hot tub!

Stayed in June 2025

Lovely, clean room and bathroom, delicious breakfast, engaging hosts, service above and beyond the norm

Stayed in March 2025

Welcoming!

Stayed in August 2024

Mark and Ari were so welcoming, the room was very comfortable and breakfast was delicious - also enjoyed swimming in the pool!

Stayed in July 2024

The innkeepers were fantastic and very friendly and hospitable. Enjoyed our stay and wish the weather cooperated better so we could have enjoyed the pool and grounds more!

Stayed in July 2024

The owners went out of their way to pick us up from the airport upon our arrival and take us to the train station for our departure. Very knowledgeable of the area with lots of advice on places to visit.

Stayed in June 2024

This is an older house that has furniture appropriate to its style which is part of its charm. Be forewarned, the stairs are steep if you book an upstairs room. The bluestone lot makes it trickier to wheel luggage. They shared future plans for upgrades to the property which will make it even better.

The hosts were excellent, charming and accommodating. The continental breakfast was tasty and included homemade baked goods. The location was in a pleasant neighborhood that was convenient to transportation and within walking distance to restaurants and downtown area. The room included a really comfortable bed, a mini fridge, a coffee maker and a nice shower.

Stayed in May 2024

My sister and I really enjoyed our time here. Ari and Mark were so accommodating. They felt like family immediately. In the morning Ari baked items for breakfast (even early for us since we were on a set schedule )and Mark drove us to the airport so we could pick up our rental car. The bnb is in a good location, walking distance to Sayville's Main St, the library and the train station. The rooms are clean and beautiful. The bed and linens were really comfortable and the private bathroom had a massive tub in it.

Stayed in October 2023

This is a true B&B where the hosts greet you, offer a welcome drink, and chat you up a bit. Mark and Ari are both interesting and affable. In addition to the welcome drink, there is a full cash bar. Delicious homemade bread and cakes for breakfast. Room was modern, clean, comfortable, and the pool area/backyard are spectacular. A short walk from the station if you arrive by train. Perfect spot to stay before ferrying to Fire Island, or taking in the local attractions.

Stayed in September 2023

A little lacking space for luggage but it was manageable.

Breakfast was outstanding, very accommodating, food was delicious and served well.

Stayed in August 2023

The hosts were very hospitable and welcoming people. I had interesting conversations with them, and they helped make my stay one of the most exceptional experiences that I've ever been through. God bless them. Greetings, Marcel

Stayed in August 2023

I can only say I wish I had more time.

I was greeted by the hosts Ari and Mark who were warm and welcoming.A most charming couple. They are good conversationalists and you could spend hours talking with them. They also have a great sense of humor. Its LGBTQ friendly but anyone will feel welcome here. The inn was quaint, charming and very clean. I loved my Tammy room. Bed was firm and comfortable. Bathroom was spacious. I loved the breakfasts also. The Continental breakfast is free: Hard-boiled eggs, yogurt, granola and the most delicious baked goods made by Ari. If you want eggs and bacon, it's extra but fair. During the Summer, the backyard is the crown jewel of the inn. A luxurious heated pool, fire pit and another sitting area. I was here for a music festival and wish I had more time to spend by the beautiful pool. Also to explore the area. Sayville is a lovely and quaint little village with many dining options. The ferries to Fire Island are just a hop away. I would love to come back and explore that. I really look forward to my next visit!

Stayed in July 2023

N-O-T-H-I-N-G

Ari and Mark made me feel very comfortable and welcome. I was looking for a place to stay during a wedding so I wouldn't have to travel back home late Saturday night. I decided to make it a weekend so came out Friday and stayed til Sunday, It was 4 minutes from the wedding venue. I liked the overall feel of the house. Comfy, very clean, well decorated. My own bathroom with a big soaker tub and plenty of room in the bathroom itself. You can lock your room and bathroom if you like- key for each. I didn't feel the need but you can. Being able to adjust the room air conditioner to my liking is a plus (2nd floor- I believe the first floor has central air). Comfortable sitting choices in my room- soft chair & love seat. I found out about a fine arts show in the Hamptons because one of the artist exhibitors was staying also so I went to the show on Sunday instead of heading right home. The pool was big and beautiful though I didn't use it- I did notice that it got some shade at times. Sometimes I notice little things- the items in the room fridge were very fairly priced- not high hotel prices. Came in handy cuz I got leg cramps when I got back from wedding and hooray- tonic water in my fridge. Mark and Ari put time and attention into making the continental breakfast memorable and different each day. I'm taking this much time to review because when owners put this much effort in- they deserve it. Ari & I also spent a lot of time just talking. I hope to return here again.

Stayed in July 2023

Beautiful outside space, great conversation!

Stayed in June 2023

The Englehardts were so friendly and informative about Saville and fire Island and how to get around....we would go back in a heartbeat..

Stayed in June 2023

Ari and Mark are wonderful hosts. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort. They got us the Fire Island ferry schedule and even offered to drive us to the ferry terminal. The room and soaking tub were very comfortable. A delicious breakfast was provided each morning with yogurt, fresh berries and a home made bread basket with four different delicious breads. Ari offered to cook eggs and bacon too. Mark and Ari are great company and we enjoyed many conversations with them. We highly recommend their inn. We will definitely stay there again if in the area.

Stayed in April 2023

Mark and Ari are very mindful hosts. I arrived too late for a restaurant visit and was offered a fresh, delicious pasta dish. My room was cozy and the bathroom was renovated recently. I would recommend Come As You Are to everyone who prefers a cozy personal atmosphere to standard business hotels.

Stayed in October 2022

One of the best B&B’s ever! A hidden gem. Wonderful welcome, lovely bedroom, great breakfast and incredible conversation with the hosts. Please stay here, it’s fabulous!

Stayed in October 2022

Was clean, comfortable, very accommodating. Ari and Mark were very welcoming, friendly and super nice.

Stayed in September 2022

Looked nothing like the picture in the ad. No central air and room air cond. was very noisy. Very irritating was the 'fabulous' rating by one of the ratings - it was 'good' or OK. It was in a trafficky residential area and was led to believe it was in a rural setting.

Very clean and the hosts were friendly. It was a private house and was very homey. Easy access to all major roads. Especially clean bathroom.

Stayed in July 2023

location near the bay, specialized breakfast, homemade granola.

Stayed in July 2023