Charming and beautiful historical home. Drew and Shelly were great hosts. Delicious breakfasts. Made accommodations for our allergies.

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing.

Good breakfast and helpful staff!

Stayed in August 2025

All was great

The breakfast was fresh cooked. Great selection of muffins. Beautiful glass covered room

Stayed in August 2025

The electronic lock to my room didn’t work, but I was fine with using the key.

Wonderful vintage charm, big rooms, very friendly staff.

Stayed in August 2025

Beautiful, and private! Comfortable bed and great jacuzzi!

Stayed in August 2025

The floor needs to be fixed a little better.😊

It’s a beautiful historical house! We can see the fine works. The rooms are very comfortable. The breakfast is 5 stars! We enjoyed it.

Stayed in August 2025

We had a truly lovely stay at the Benn Conger Inn. From the moment we arrived, we felt warmly welcomed. The lady who greeted us was incredibly kind and made our experience even more special by preparing a fresh breakfast for us every morning - something you do not always find, and it really made a difference. The hotel is located in a quiet, small village, which added to the peaceful atmosphere. Sometimes it's not about the rooms or the building - it's the genuine hospitality that makes a place memorable, and this stay was a perfect example of that.

Stayed in August 2025

A little pricey for the location

A beautiful Inn with great staff and a wonderful breakfast.

Stayed in August 2025

Top notch place, comfort and value. Breakfast was delicious and homemade. All the essentials for a hearty, great start to the day breakfast. Location was fantastic for us since we wanted to explore all the things the two largest Finger lakes have to offer. Best of all that stands above everything else is their personal touch and hospitality. One particular moment sums it all up. My wife had accidentally left some personal items behind. We were already so far away that couldn't go back, but Drew at the Inn was able to track the items down and personally went down to the post office to ship them to us! That's a personal touch I really didn't expect but I should have actually, since the moment we stepped foot at the Inn it really was a white glove experience from the start and of course even after we left! Lori was an amazing host as well and we felt immediately at home with her, in fact it was her childhood home, so no wonder she and Drew treat everyone as true guests to their home. Thank you Lori and Drew!

Stayed in July 2025

The only thing was there were no spoons in the room to stir coffee and there wasn’t any regular sugar.

Everything was absolutely wonderful and breakfast was delicious. 😀

Stayed in July 2025

The only suggestions to make a great stay even better, would be to have a variety of pillow options and to have a non-pork/beef breakfast meat like turkey/chicken or veggie sausage on hand for guests who don't eat pork/beef. These are things that have been available at other places we've stayed.

Everything was perfect upon arrival. Shelly made sure we were comfortable and was extremely helpful and attentive. The property was very quiet, great for a good night's sleep after hiking. We were in the Dempsey suite and enjoyed the porch with a view of rabbits and deer in the morning and evenings. Breakfast was delicious. Depending on the day there was a combination of fresh fruit, muffins, waffles and cinnamon bun French toast, as well as eggs cooked to order daily. The location worked great for exploring all the lakes and state parks in the area. Ithaca was 20 minutes away for any type of restaurant or store one would need.

Stayed in July 2025

Sidewalks in front of the house were old and uneven, not the fault of the Inn.

The staff was helpful, showed us to our room & gave history of the property. The room was beautiful, comfortable and relaxing. Breakfast was delicious.

Stayed in July 2025

The breakfast was made to order and delish. Such a relaxing atmosphere

Stayed in June 2025

Charming Inn in a quiet location. Friendly and accommodating staff. Nice breakfast options. Comfy bed. Large bathroom. Loved having a balcony. Ample parking. Would happily stay there again.

Stayed in June 2025

Too short of a stay we had

Very nice property, comfy rooms with historic feel, great service, and a very good breakfast.

Stayed in June 2025

N/A

Extremely clean and pleasant environment. The flower garden outside the dining room window was in full bloom.

Stayed in June 2025

Had small issue to get in suite but Drew responded quickly to resolve.

Overnight getaway to Benn Conger Inn. Stayed in the Dempsey house. Room was cozy and comfortable. Decorated beautifully with paintings and antiques. Very quiet relaxing. A cool place with a cool story.

Stayed in June 2025

Savory breakfast options could not cater to our dietary needs (no pork). However we spoke to Drew who was more than happy and interested to work on this feedback to ensure more inclusivity.

Very clean, beautiful place.

Stayed in June 2025

Room was small but very nice and comfortable. Enjoyed the balcony

Nice, clean room, friendly and helpful staff. Excellent breakfast. Enjoyed our stay

Stayed in June 2025

The Benn Conger Inn is a step back to a simpler time but with every amenity. It is charming and sparkles with good clean energy. The food is delicious at breakfast and the peace I found there was enchanting!

Stayed in June 2025

I loved the hotel! Lovely decorated rooms, kind staff and amazing breakfast!

Stayed in May 2025

No coffee stirres for my coffee, no ice for my water.

Comfortable bed, cleanliness of the facility, coziness and the decor.

Stayed in May 2025

What a lovely place to stay! Everything was clean and well kept! Shelley is delightful and the staff was welcoming and friendly.

Stayed in May 2025

N/A

Everything! Staff, location, breakfast, rooms, character and uniqueness of the house

Stayed in May 2025