It was a very nice location, with a shared pool and great access to the ocean with free use of the kayaks. The staff was very friendly and helpful to organize my dive trips.

Stayed in August 2025

It was a very nice place to stay very comfortable. The staff was very nice and the room was very clean.

Stayed in August 2025

During my stay the free WiFi was either slow or non-existent. The staff were aware and did their best to have it fixed (which it was). Still... it was frustrating to rely on 4G data package.

A very nice hotel offering good facilities and access to a private beach. The whole place promotes a relaxing and unrushed stay... Tamed squirrels are hopping around alongside with iguanas of various colours and sizes... super tropical and feels close to nature. The staff, particularly Jonathan, were very helpful and friendly. There's plenty of local knowledge and recommendations; I rented a push bike and had a tyre puncture (rental car) fixed on Jonathan's recommendation. Aside from all the practicalities, Bay Harbour Lodge is a little beach paradise, which is priceless.

Stayed in August 2025

Did not find anything we didn’t like.

Everything! Room was clean and cozy. The coffee and pastries in the morning were delicious! Staff is very friendly and helpful. 100% recommend Bay Harbor Lodge.

Stayed in July 2025

nothing

everything

Stayed in July 2025

Complimentary coffee and scones in the morning, clean rooms and gorgeous property. Stayed for a night on our way to Key West and will definitely stay again.

Stayed in July 2025

Very nice, well-maintained property. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Cari served up excellent scones and coffee for the free breakfast. We would love to stay here again.

Stayed in June 2025

Flying insects

Awesome location. Homely quiet feel. Great hosts. Pool on site along with beach access.

Stayed in May 2025

Older units so they have thin walls and floors. Could hear people walking upstairs and some of talking next door. But you just have to take that with a grain of salt. That can happen anywhere.

Very sweet property. Beautifully maintained and lots of tropical plants and. The room was updated and nicely decorated. The pool was very refreshing and clean. Kayaks at the dock. amazing morning scones homemade. Staff was so friendly and accommodating. Can watch sunset right on property at the Bay front. Lots of places to relax with or without shade. Quiet and quaint little retreat. Bed was very comfy.

Stayed in May 2025

Only one complaint: It is very difficult to find the entrance from the highway (the very busy highway) and we passed it by a few times, a challenge other guests experienced as well.

This is a little gem! The location is great; you are close to all Key Largo sites and experiences. The property itself is lovely and the tropical landscaping is gorgeous. Our studio room was spotless and well-appointed. The staff was welcoming and helpful; there were multiple options to enjoy the pool and this beach-bayfront property. All kinds of water play and equipment are at the ready from kayaks and paddleboards to snorkels and noodle floaties. The sunsets are magnificent! The hosts even have an assortment of board games for those who would rather just chill. Each morning, Peggy prepares an incredible variety of fresh scones and hot and cold beverages, served with smiles from her on-site Food Truck. No detail that creates a pleasant morning is missed (The iced coffee even has coffee ice cubes!). Seating? There are too many options to list in any of the main grounds or bayfront settings! We would definitely stay at the Bay Harbor again.

Stayed in May 2025

Cant think of much to criticise. If I had to fins something I would say that the Lodge is not within walking distance of many facilities and you need to take a short drive (< 5mins) to get to Restaurants etc. But, frankly you have to drive everywhere anyway, and you would not get the type of experience that we had in the area where the restaurants/bars are mainly concentrated. Key Largo is bisected by US1 which is quite a busy (ish) road do there is a low level noise from this road in the background , didn't bother me at all apart form the occasional loud motorbike and at night its no issue. Of course the keys is a fairly narrow strip of land with this highway running its length so I can't imagine that issue is unique to BHL.

Loved it. We stayed in a lodge with a view of the Bay. This a small hotel with perhaps 25 rooms/lodges, about 1.5 miles from the main parts of Key Largo. For us , it was perfect, it has a small beach with Kayaks to use and chairs etc to sit, sunbathe etc. There's no breakfast provided as such but Scone sand drinks are provided which was a nice touch. The Lodge had bedroom, Kitchen, bathroom and sitting area. It was small, but then we we rarely in it except for the occasional meal and of course to sleep. There was a table outside the lodge for our use only with a view across the Bay. The view is great the water incredibly calm and perfect for Kayaking, swimming, just look out for Manatees. Highly recommend for a quiet stay in a fabulous part of the Keys. Host provided great restaurant and activity recommendations, Highly recommend. We arrived late at night at a time when the office is shut (after 8pm) but the host provided easy instructions to get to our Lodge which was excellent.

Stayed in April 2025

Home made scones included for breakfast

Stayed in March 2025

We left Miami Beach and stopped in Key Largo for the night on the way to Key West.The property was beautiful and peaceful

Stayed in March 2025

Fresh coffee, tea and hot chocolate with daily homemade scones were a lovely addition to our stay. There were kayaks and SUPs to borrow, and the beach/dock area had a beautiful view of the sunset.

Stayed in March 2025

The room was a bit stuffy

Everything: clean and beautiful location

Stayed in March 2025

Several tiki huts, many tables/chairs and lounge areas for enjoying the outdoors. Charming, small resort atmosphere. The nicest, most accommodating hosts. Beautiful sunset view.

Stayed in February 2025

Friendly staff, modern clean facilities, plenty of parking and very cozy atmosphere. Excellent location middle of Key Largo. Highly recommended.

Stayed in January 2025

Great scones and loved the setting

Stayed in February 2025

Great scones and complimentary kayak

Stayed in December 2024

Wonderful spirit

Stayed in December 2024

—

I loved the location, fresh Peg’s scones every morning, the possibilities to use kayak for free and very friendly atmosphere. It’s a wonderful quite place.

Stayed in November 2024

What a wonderful small resort! Right on the beach, with free kayaks, paddleboards and beach toys. The room was spacious and fully stocked. Staff were so friendly and helpful. But our favorite part was the delicious fresh scones each morning with several new flavors each day and fresh coffee and tea. Such a lovely getaway!

Stayed in November 2024

The grounds and room were meticulously clean. They didn't nickel and dime us to death. We had our own designated parking spot (free) and access to complimentary kayaks and fabulous scones and coffee every morning! The staff were all friendly and accommodating.

Stayed in November 2024

I can’t say anything negative

It is private, quiet, and the grounds are very well maintained. Each room is individual and separate from each other so you’re more secluded. We loved everything about the property!

Stayed in October 2024