Restaurant servers meals Tuesday - Saturday only (food is excellent btw) so Sunday/Monday we had to make different arrangements for dinner which was bit bothering. But we were offered sandwiches during days restaurant was closed.

Beautifully renovated lodge with lovely garden and great food! We were enjoying sunsets in the garden a lot while sipping wine and chatting to Tonny - the owner. Highly recommend this place & Isle of Mull to those who prefer quiet holidays. We loved it!

Stayed in August 2025

Nothing

A perfect place to visit isle of Mull. Everything was just perfect. House, room, food, staff. Our favorite stay during our vacation in Scotland

Stayed in August 2025

The restaurant does not operate on Sunday evening. Whilst we understand the staff need a rest, other dining options in the area are very limited. If you plan to stay on a Sunday, need to make plans on where to dine outside the guesthouse.

Breakfast was excellent. Dinner had a limited menu but was also excellent. Staff were very friendly, highly competent and extremely helpful. We had a lovely room overlooking the ferry port, highly recommended. Location is also good for visiting north of the island and also a trip to Iona.

Stayed in August 2025

There was nothing not to like.

Everything. Fiona and Agna we're always friendly and helpful and Agna couldn't have provided us with better service.

Stayed in August 2025

Not many places to eat in Craignure but great location for the ferry especially if you dont drive.

View was stunning, beautiful accomodation, great breakfast and excellent hosts.

Stayed in July 2025

Nothing

Beautiful garden, lovely house

Stayed in July 2025

Great room, quiet & convenient location

Stayed in June 2025

Brighter reading lights for ageing eyes would be very helpful

Breakfast was good and the homemade granola was very special. The Lodge is set in beautiful gardens about 10 minutes walk from the ferry terminal. There is a lovely lounge, well furnished and with some great paintings. The view over the garden and the sea is stunning. Our room was spacious and comfortable with the same view. The owners were very welcoming and did all they could to make our stay comfortable.

Stayed in June 2025

That we couldn't stay longer!

The location is convenient and beautiful, within sight of the CalMac ferry terminal at Craignure, and on a slight hill with a gorgeous view of the sunsets. The gardens are lovely as well. We opted for the Duart room, which has a freestanding tub with the same amazing view! The room was spacious and comfortable, with all the little touches you would expect from an inn of this level: tea kettle, coffee and tea options, snacks, hair dryer; soaps and lots of fluffy towels. But I haven't even started talking about the food yet! Heavenly! Chef Michael's creations are inspired! I only wish I hadn't been so keen to eat them I forgot to take photos! Everything from starters to deserts to breakfasts were delicious! Ate dinner there two out of three nights, abs would have made it three but our schedule had us in Tobermory at dinner our second night. We also had two box lunches prepared for us to take on our day trips, and they were fantastic! All in all, I can't say enough great things about everyone at Pennygate! Tony and Fiona are marvelous hosts, and their staff is the best!

Stayed in June 2025

All was perfect.

The room and bed were very comfortable. The bathroom was a nice size. The dinner we had there was super good. The breakfasts were made to order and quickly served. Tony was a seriously nice and kind man and and his garden like the B&B was immaculate! The garden was a nice place to chill outside and enjoy the view. The location was minutes from the ferry to Oban. I would definitely return.

Stayed in May 2025

All was good for us

The restaurant was trust excellent with friendly service. I asjes for wine recommendations which were great. We did not finish the bottel but no problem it was kept for us for the next day! Very cosy rooms, luxurious finishing. People have thought this through. View on harbour from the large lounge. .

Stayed in April 2025

The room was extremely comfortable and well provided of everything necessary for a conformable stay. The room cleanliness was superb and it was well provided of towels, bathrobes, soaps, kettle, teas, tv, blankets and pillows. The breakfast was good and the staff was extremely friendly.

Stayed in May 2025

Smallish room

The meals were carefully prepared , nutritious local produce and served by excellent staff who went out of their way to help. The room had lovely extra touches like real milk and cold water in a fridge. Really great walk in shower.

Stayed in May 2025

Everything about this lodge is excellent. Loads of thought has gone into making your stay very comfortable. Great produce ensured fantastic food.

Stayed in March 2025

The breakfast included a self serve part, and a selection from a menu. All this was included in the room charge.

Stayed in October 2024

TV a bit small but because of great weather we did not get to use it, anyway!

Great location near the ferry to Oban! Very good breakfasts and the restaurant on the property served amazing food at reasonable prices and their wine list was great, too. Mathew was very knowledgeable about the wines and a terrific host for dinners. The beds were comfortable and really nice bathroom and shower!

Stayed in September 2024

The friendliness of staff who were keen to go the extra mile. The amazing food, the gardens!

Stayed in September 2024

Nothing

The breakfast was great. There were plenty of fruit and cereals options as well as a full cooked breakfasts, plenty of choice.

Stayed in September 2024

Can’t think of anything

Homely feel and excellent food

Stayed in September 2024

We had to go home 😢

We loved the views of the sea and peir from the front windows. The period box sash windows all fully restored to modern standards kweping the original designs replicated perfectly. The decor was superb and spotless and when we went down for breakfast. The dining room was beautifully lit and elegant. This really was pleasant and the food quality along with the wonderfully friendky service just made it all the better 😍

Stayed in September 2024

It’s difficult to think of anything.

Comfortable, clean and tastefully decorated. All the staff were friendly and helpful. The garden is beautiful.

Stayed in September 2024

It was a lovely lodge for B&B, and I would go again, but a tad expensive.

Location was very quiet but close enough to walk to the local pub and even the ferry. We had 2 evening meals, and they were both excellent. Breakfasts were very good. Room was very clean and comfortable with a view out to the ferry.

Stayed in August 2024

Absolutely nothing

The location and view was superb. The rooms were extremely comfortable and had everything you needed for your stay. The staff were so welcoming and it felt like home from home. The onsite restaurant was unreal. The food was unbelievable. Matthew could not do enough, making the restaurant a relaxed environment. Pauline, the chef was a wizard in the kitchen both evening meals and breakfasts. We will 100% be back to Pennygate lodge and will be recommending this property to anyone we know who will be visiting the island. Angela and Alan

Stayed in August 2024

The rooms are not the largest and it seems that there are no twin bed options.

Very comfortable and modern room. Tony is an exceptional host. We got a second duvet on request, there's tea and coffee in the room, the lounge downstairs is very cozy. Spectacular dinner, had the chance to get a spontaneous slot, usually would recommend to book ahead. Matthew, who's in charge with service there (his wife is the chef in the kitchen), was lovely and even helped us to get acquainted with whiskey. Breakfast is also provided by him and his wife and we totally recommend the scottish breakfast. Best Haggis we've ever had!

Stayed in August 2024