The 4 best hotels in Oyster Bay

based on 935 hotel reviews on Booking.com

• Oyster Bay Resort

  #1 of 4 hotels in Oyster Bay

  Last review posted: 2 days ago

  See the property

  • “Everything was perfect for us, we really enjoyed our stay!”
  • “”
  • “”
  • See more reviews of Oyster Bay Resort

  
• Tiny House with HOT TUB, close to golf and hiking!!

  #2 of 4 hotels in Oyster Bay

  Last review posted: 5 days ago

  See the property

  • “Loved my stay and was sad it was only 1 night.”
  • “It was wonderful. Would stay there again”
  • “highly recommended”
  • See more reviews of Tiny House with HOT TUB, close to golf and hiking!!

  
• Ocean Resort

  #3 of 4 hotels in Oyster Bay

  Last review posted: 5 days ago

  See the property

  • “”
  • “”
  • “Beautiful location between the ocean and the highway.”
  • See more reviews of Ocean Resort
  • • Boutique Hotels

  
• Edgewater Motel

  #4 of 4 hotels in Oyster Bay

  Last review posted: 5 days ago

  See the property

  • “”
  • “”
  • “Dated but comfortable”
  • See more reviews of Edgewater Motel